Goldsmiths Tales Toolkit Trial and Violence in Story
Tags
impact-assessment
research-science
diversity-inclusion
socio-emotional
Subscribe to access all areas
Support your entire team’s CPD with our full webinar back catalogue
Get emails when new webinars are released
Dr Alice Jones Bartoli
Senior Lecturer & Director Of Unit Of School And Family Studies, Goldsmiths University
Dr Alice Jones Bartoli, BSc PGCert PhD
Senior Lecturer and Director of Unit of School and Family Studies, Goldsmiths, University of London.
WEBVTT - This file was automatically generated by VIMEO. Please email info@talestoolkit.com to report problems.
So you do the training right now, um,
and you get, I think, a lot of opportunity
to provide useful feedback,
but also for us to think about, you know, is this useful
for a particular group of children?
And if so, how can we perhaps capitalize on that
and do something more useful
or more targeted at certain groups of children?
So it, it provides us with also a kind of a decent baseline,
but also avenues for, for further,
um, research and opportunity.
Okay. Okay. Click. Okay.
So who, who is involved with this?
So first of all, uh, you, all of you, um,
and we plan to work with every preschool
and nursery, um,
who are involved in this particular training
and also some that will be involved in the next training.
Right. Um, so we will be, if we,
if we haven't already, we will be sending packs out to you,
um, that contain, uh, teacher packs and uh, parent letters.
Um, and I can talk a bit more about that if it's helpful.
In fact, here might be a good point for you to kind
of write some questions about how things work if,
if you want to, and I can address those as we go along.
Um, mm-Hmm. We will come to visit you, um,
if we are able, so we, we're, we're working on quite a, a,
a teeny budget for this.
So we, we don't have lots of money.
Um, I'm afraid to come and visit everybody, but we will try
and visit a decent proportion of schools.
Um, and in the meantime we can happily, um,
organize Skype contacts, uh, contacts
or telephone conversations or email conversations
or anything else that we need to, with, with people
that we won't come visit directly.
Our team is quite small.
Um, so there are, there are four of us at the minute, um,
and we are made up of, uh, me, um, my two students
who will be doing a lot of the work on the project, um, up
until I guess next February.
Um, so Alice at the top there who, uh, has blonde hair
and then below her with the lovely Kelly hair.
Um, so it's, it's, it's pretty simple.
50% of our team is called Alice,
so it should be reasonably simple for people to work with,
um, who will be our, uh, Guinea pig, um,
to, um, kind of let us run through the things
that we're going to do with the children with him first.
So Alice, Anita should be well trained in dealing with, uh,
three year olds with a mind of their own by the time they,
uh, they come to see you.
Mm-Hmm. And you've been using the kit
with Alo at home, haven't you?
Alice? Have, I have. He is delighted. Uh, he loves it.
He loves it. And I, I know that,
that your children do as well.
Um, in fact, when, when he saw the little thing
that you had little picture of the character flash up on one
of your slides, did you hear him?
No. The problem
He asked, sorry, can we play the problem game?
He, he thinks the whole thing's brilliant.
Yeah. So it's great.
Alice has been showing me some really cool videos
of him telling stories as well, so, so that's, so yeah.
And there was some violence in
his stories too, wasn't there, Alice?
There's a lot, there's a lot of hitting going on in the
that child, which, uh, me slightly.
That's it. So yeah. Do you want me to click?
Yep. Yep. Cool.
Okay. So where are we doing this?
So if we can, then we'll come to you.
Um, so we start with London schools
and we'll visit others as soon as we can.
And all we need when we come to you is a quiet space, um,
where we can work with one child at a time, um, on their own
or, or with an adult present,
if that's the most useful thing to do.
Um, it does, doesn't need to be a place outside
or, you know, completely secluded from room, just in a sort
of quiet corner wherever you kind of might usually do more.
Uh, quiet work with, with children.
Mm-Hmm. Yep.
Oh, hello Alice.
Oh, hello. I think we, I've lost Alice
for a minute There you back.
Okay.
Hello Alice,
can you hear me?
Oh, can, can everybody hear me?
Have you lost Alice as well, or is that just me?
Oh, okay. Right. Well, I tell you what,
how about while I wait for Alice
to come back in, we've, oh, hello.
Alice, are you back? I'll tell you
what, while we're waiting for Alice to come back,
I've got a film that I could play, which is, um,
showing children exploring violence tree story.
And then when Alex comes back in,
we can flick it back into it.
So let me play this for you.
What's gonna happen to the chicken? Die. She's gonna die.
Oh, oh, oh. Can you show me how you die?
Oh, oh, that's,
Oh no. The chicken
said what can we do? How is that gonna help?
The
Why was the goat to problem?
Because he had,
So the goats got horns
and he wanted to fight with the cow.
That was a problem. So first he tried
mooing at the goat.
Did the goat go away?
No. No.
Oh, no. So the gigantic goat was trying
to hurt him with his horn.
He trying to cut him in half of his, he
Was trying to cut him in half
with his horns that needs him.
Oh no. What's the cow gonna do? He tried mooing.
What else could the cow do?
Solution bag. Maybe, maybe there's a dinosaur in there.
Oh. Oh, it's not a dinosaur, is it?
You could and try
to run. Oh,
Okay. You could try
that.
Oh, if he die, he might die. He
Might die.
Oh, no. Bad. He's the bad
Problem.
He is the problem. But does that mean he needs to die?
Look, his angry face. He's got a angry face.
Creepy. Oh.
Oh, do you know what? I don't like that.
That's made me even angrier.
Can you show me your angry faces?
I'm so angry that I'm gonna give him a really
big push on the act.
Fake it. Fake it like that.
Ted, how could that be the solution?
Um, um, cut head. Really? Do you reckon?
Could be. Oh.
Oh. Hello. Hello.
I've, I've lost my head. I forgot a bed anymore.
How am I gonna eat my dinner? Is the bear happy or sad? Now?
Sad. Oh, is he happy or sad?
Now I'd be sad, cat.
So we didn't end up very happy, did we? What can we do?
How could we help the hair cat?
Now we've got Another problem. Um, can I make better?
What can we do? I put stack paper in to make it feel better.
So, um, what
and how, so there are two things that we want to do
with, with children.
Um, first is a really simple receptive vocabulary, um, test.
And the reason that we want to do this is to answer one
of our questions about how well Tales toolkit works
for children whose language, um, is,
is very good, is kind of less good, I think.
So children who might have some language delay, are they,
are they still able to, to kind
of gain from it in the same way
that other children might be?
Um, it's a very, very simple task.
So children are given, uh, four pictures to choose from,
and then they're given a word
and they need to point to the picture that matches the word.
So very simple stuff.
Um, the social problem solving task, um,
will probably work better for slightly older children.
And here we, we give children a very short scenario
and ask them what they would do.
So a scenario that they'd be totally used to something
that might happen in nursery, somebody snatches something
from them or something similar.
And we ask, you know, what, what,
what do you do in this situation?
So we're interested in, um, kind of flexibility in,
in problem solving, um,
and the sort of ideas that, that children come up with
and how they might change over time.
So then we also want key workers to comment,
and you've probably seen the pacs already on behavior,
on children's relationship with peers and with staff.
Um, and then we're also going
to collect some story examples from you.
And I know that you're already sending those, those, uh,
back to, to, to Kate and to me as well.
So that's really helpful. And hello? Hello.
New people who are here. Hello Jackie.
Um, okay. So are there any questions
before I shift on about the evaluation?
Got a few few questions coming in now this is, this is good.
If you haven't received your pack, would you just, um,
type in where you are from
and then I'll, I'll be able to to, to chase it up.
Good. Cool. Yeah. Good.
So we, oh, we've got Saskia haven't got a kit yet.
A pack yet. Okay. Pauline has, Liz has.
So yeah, so lots of packs going out. That's great.
There were a lot of packs. Yes. Hello?
Saskia from First Steps. Yeah. Brilliant.
So Alex needs some parents letters, so yeah. Great.
Do, do you wanna explain Alice about
how the parent letters work?
Yes, I will. Mm-Hmm.
So, um, we have ethical permission to work on a,
um, passive consent basis.
So what we do is send letters out
and if parents don't respond at all,
then we assume that they're okay.
However, we are also interested in maybe following up some
work with parents, um, which means
that they may return the slip that has their kind
of best way to contact them on address
so that we can contact parents without
to nurseries and cause extra bother.
So it might be that you get a bunch
of slips back from parents.
Um, and if so, either send those back
to us in your prepaid envelopes or,
So Liz was just asking while we're waiting for Alice
to get back on how she would like us
to record the Charles toolkit sessions.
If you are up for video in your sessions, we would love
to see a video of your session.
So that's ideally the perfect way,
but we're also happy for you to scribe stories.
Um, I know Rachel, who's just logged in,
she's been using the kit for quite a long time
and she scribes stories
and she sends links to those to me on Twitter.
Um, so that we can see the stories
that our children are telling.
Um, so you scribing those stories are absolutely fine,
but I would say if you are scribing the stories,
either have a member of staff with you during the session
that can write notes or just go with the flow
and then at the end make whatever notes you
can to remember that session.
So don't worry about fitting
that in while you are actually
telling the tells toolkit story.
So yeah, Alice is gonna go and sign back in.
Does that make sense? So Jane Shelley is online.
Um, so she's asking, um, should I actually ask the children
to be kind and know hurting when using the kit,
or do I just go with it?
Um, I would say just go with it.
So go with the flow and feed it into their play.
So when we show the clips,
which I'll have access feed afterwards,
so you can watch those again.
Um, just go with the flow
and feed in things like feeling words
and get the children to start recognizing when someone's sad
or unhappy or it makes somebody cross
and use all those feeling words and stories, um,
and just explore it with the children.
So I think when you start to make it about right and wrong
and being kind and no hurting, then it becomes a safe, like
that, that space where it's difficult for them
to explore the things that they really want to explore.
So everything is absolutely fine.
Okay. Um, so, um, we were thinking about, um, how
typical it is for children to talk about, um, aggressive
and violent situations in their stories.
Um, and in fact it, it's pretty normal.
So I've been doing some research about this
and there's some really fascinating work
on children's storytelling.
Um, so one study that I looked at, um, which was, um,
on preschoolers in the states reported that, um,
just over a third of nearly 900 stories, um,
from preschool aged children included aggressive actions.
Um, and while the majority of those came from boys, um,
actually it was pretty close in number.
So I think it was something like kind of, uh, 58% of, of,
uh, the stories were boy stories
and only 42 or girl stories.
So really, really close,
actually far closer than than we might think.
So what we think is going on when children use, um,
aggressive stories, um,
or um, use aggressive vocabulary in their stories is, is
that what they're trying
to do often makes sense of the world.
So to examine the world and to ask questions,
but also organize it.
So storytelling is a really safe place
to test some boundaries.
So when we have a child who does something quite, uh,
inappropriate who might be, um, hitting or pushing
or or hurting somebody else, what
what they're really doing is, is also checking
with you what that's like.
So, you know, I'm, I'm hitting this thing to move it out
to the way you see, often children will kind of check
with the adult in the room about whether that's okay.
Um, and then this is a nice point to go, well, you know,
maybe we could do something else, or,
or, or something similar.
Some stories are about exploring what happens
to the child themselves.
Um, and you can, you can see that the children kind
of replay scenes
or stories that they know about that have happened to them
or to other people and others are purely fictional, um,
and related to fantasy.
And they might be based on stories that they know about.
Um, but also they, they might not be also quite,
sometimes aggression and violence
and stuff can sometimes make stories a bit more exciting.
Um, and sometimes that
that's something which is, is used as well.
This, this is a really nice slide, I think, which shows us
proportion of words used,
which were different types of aggressive acts.
So what's really interesting is, is the type of words used
and also where the aggressive act happen.
So quite often the aggressive hack acts towards, um,
happen towards a non-human
or some other fantastical creature.
So dragons, monsters, aliens, they are kind of the,
the three most likely elements in children's door or hurt.
And this is really interesting
because I think it demonstrates
that children have an understanding
between fiction and reality.
So it's probably to kill a dragon or an alien
because they're, they're not real anyway.
Um, so it's kind of more acceptable, I think for children
to explore aggression in that context.
Very few children's stories also involved a weapon,
or particularly specific in their aggressive act.
So they say something like,
I killed the dragon rather than I stabbed it
with my sword, for example.
And again, I I think this is about children kind of
reaching a means to an end quite quickly without really
thinking about what the aggressive act might look like.
Um, so I think in this way we,
we can feel slightly more comfortable if,
if these are the kinds of stories
that we're guessing quite kind of abstract
and fantastical ways of, of getting rid of problems.
We can feel reasonably comfortable that, that it,
it's reasonably typical that these things happen.
It is a little bit more concerning I think, when
they're either very specific or towards specific people.
So, um, one of the, the research pieces that,
that I was reading about talked about a, a child who,
who says something like, I shot my sister,
which is pretty brutal for a, a preschooler
to be, to be talking about.
So what do we do about it? What should we respond?
Like, okay, so we can respond to aggressive play, first
of all by reinforcing the idea that plays pretend.
So, okay, well, you know, this, this is a,
a pretend situation.
So this, this is a safe place for us to do this.
Um, and to try and think about alternative behaviors
and alternative resolutions also to help children kind
of humanize their enemy in this, in this context.
So helping children to understand the effects
of aggression and violence.
Um, so thinking about how we can help children to understand
that the person they're killing
or being aggressive towards is, is a person.
Um, depending on the context, it might be, um,
interesting to think about what's being said more closely.
So with some children, it might be okay to kind
of let the story develop in this way in another
group of children who that might have, um,
experience domestic violence
or something similar in the home, then, um,
we might need to, we might need
to think about working in it in a slightly different way.
Mm-Hmm. So the point is that the stories can be used
as a starting about violence
and aggression, um, that helps us think about
working with particular children.
Um, does that make sense?
Yes, that makes sense. Um, Alice,
is there any detriment if you've got children
that are exposed to violence at home, um,
and that's the normal way of life for them
and that's what happens for them
and their families, is there any detriment in you talking
about it being wrong?
What's the best way to go about discussing violence
with children that are exposed to it in their daily life?
I think it's definitely fine
to say, I think children know it.
They know it's wrong. They do.
Um, because all the modeling that, that you get at nursery
or, or somewhere else kind of and,
and any aggressive behavior
that they demonstrate at nursery is going to be, you know,
kind of dealt with in inappropriate way.
So I think children have a very strong sense
that hurting other people
and behaving aggressively to other people is wrong
when it's about in a story context, I think it's okay
to explore that a little, little bit gently
and help them make sense of what's,
what's going on in their lives as well in some ways.
Mm-Hmm. So I think it's nice to say, well, do you know
what I, I'm not sure that's the best way
of dealing with this situation.
Is there anything else that we can do Mm-Hmm.
So without maybe kind of saying words like, no, that's wrong
or that's that bad,
but just, just allowing a, a kind of exploration
for the child to think about a, an alternative
or a different way of dealing with things. Yep. Yep.
That's good. Um, is anybody,
do you want me to click to the next one?
Is that the Sure,
Yeah. Yeah.
Um, so
I think that was kind of pretty much a kind
of whistle stop tour to Mm-Hmm.
As a, as a starting point.
And then I'm really happy to answer question and,
and think about it with you in, in useful way. Yeah.
Uh, and it's quite interesting.
We've got some great stories coming through.
So Rachel was saying that, um, just a minute ago
that she's seen development over time in terms
of her children's storytelling.
Um, and that last year they used to hit the character
or punch or bite, but then they started to make magic spells
and find more prosocial solutions in their stories.
Um, and Liz, Liz eighties come up, she said that, um,
her group, uh, was beating up the big bad wolf with blocks,
but then when he used the sad voice
and said, stop, you're hurting me, then they showed empathy
and one little boy said, okay, let's be friends.
So there's some interesting stories coming through
or have you, you've seen some really good
Strategies there, can't you, about kind of humanizing and,
and suggesting that we empathize.
So giving a fantastical creature like the big bad wolf, um,
an emotion that children can easily, easily kind of
recognize and, and correspond with is, is a really neat way,
I think, of kind of helping to develop empathy towards a,
a character who, who you call bad, that
that's what we call them, right?
Mm-Hmm. Yeah.
Um, what are your thoughts, Alice, on um, the use
of words like naughty or bad, um,
and things like that in stories,
The words which children use,
they pick up on those words really, really easily.
So, um, I'm not sure
whether those words are really used in
preschools, anniversaries anyway.
Mm-Hmm. So the words that children might bring, um,
and in which case that that's kind of fine
'cause that's their vocabulary.
But again, I think it's fine to just explore those words
and check them a little
and go do, do we mean, you know, well why is that naughty
and is it naughty and you know, is it really bad or,
or is there an alternative?
So in just the same way that you would a,
a child calling another child naughty Mm-Hmm.
Would usually check that
Yes. Or
Think of an alternative.
So the same kind of thing I think is okay. Okay. Um,
Oh great. So we've got a comment
from Alex saying, uh,
she feels better prepared to deal with issues
that are likely to come up
because they will come up in stories.
I know from everyone that uses tells toolkit stories,
it's something that does come up at the beginning.
Um, and it will be something that you'll all be exposed to
and it's really worth as a school, having those discussions.
Heading 1
Heading 2
Heading 3
Heading 4
Heading 5
Heading 6
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur.
Block quote
Ordered list
- Item 1
- Item 2
- Item 3
Unordered list
- Item A
- Item B
- Item C
Bold text
Emphasis
Superscript
Subscript